Elsevier Author Services – Articles
  • Research Process
  • Manuscript Preparation
  • Manuscript Review
  • Publication Process
  • Publication Recognition
  • Language Editing Services
  • Translation Services
  • Language Editing Services
  • Translation Services
Facebook
LinkedIn
YouTube
WeChat
x
Elsevier QRcode Wechat
Elsevier Author Services – Articles
Language Editing Services by Elsevier Author Services
Elsevier Author Services – Articles
  • Research Process
  • Manuscript Preparation
  • Manuscript Review
  • Publication Process
  • Publication Recognition
  • English
    • 简体中文
AI in Manuscript Editing
  • Manuscript Review

Is The Use of AI in Manuscript Editing Feasible? Here’s Three Tips to Steer Clear of Potential Issues

  • 4 minute read
  • 16.6K views
Total
0
Shares
0
0
0
0
0

Table of Contents

  • Analyzing context and grasping nuances in writing 
  • Maintaining the sensitivity of content
  • Providing disclosure and following strict academic ethics

Presently, generative artificial intelligence (hereinafter referred to as AI) is quietly influencing almost every industry, including scientific research and academic writing. Some researchers are exploring AI-based editors to refine papers and enhance writing quality. Though AI-based editors can help authors rewrite sentences and catch grammatical errors¹, it doesn’t mean that complete reliance on AI for academic writing is advisable. Human review remains essential. 

When using AI to assist academic writing, authors must pay close attention to aspects such as contextual analysis, accuracy in expression, cultural sensitivity, and academic ethics; doing this can help avoid many common issues. Now, let’s take a look at 3 key points to keep in mind when using AI-based editors for academic writing! 

 

  1. Analyzing context and grasping nuances in writing 

Writing an academic paper requires in-depth knowledge of the subject (including recent advances in the field). Editing it also requires this context; without it an editor may change the meaning of what a paper is saying.
 

For example, consider this sentence: 

“While the researcher introduced the participants the sample images appeared one by one on the screen.” 

Here, the author could have missed adding some context and punctuation. After editing, this could read: 

“While the researcher introduced the participants to the sample images, the latter appeared one by one on the screen.” 

Or 

“While the researcher introduced the participants, the sample images appeared one by one on the screen.”
 

Choosing the option that accurately reflects the writer’s original intention requires native-level English proficiency and robust academic writing experience. An experienced human editor with a clear understanding of nuance and context would be able to do it. However, an AI-based editor may not be trained on such data. Normally, data for training AI is diverse and not subject-specific knowledge. Another consideration is that a well-written manuscript summarizes the findings of a study accurately without overstating or understating them. To meet these expectations, a thorough human review post AI editing is crucial to ensure your complex ideas come across clearly to readers.
 

  1. Maintaining the sensitivity of content

AI learns based on big data, mostly generated by humans. However, all of its training data is not screened and therefore, may have biased²⁻³ or inappropriate expressions in content involving gender, race, culture, etc. AI-based editors may inherently mirror these biases. In order to avoid such mistakes, AI-edited work still needs to be carefully reviewed and screened, manually, to avoid misrepresentation in cultural and other aspects.
 

  1. Providing disclosure and following strict academic ethics

Recently, accusations of plagiarism have been leveled against AI-powered articles published by some popular news channels⁴. The problem of plagiarism is even more serious in academia. In rigorous academic writing, caution is more essential when using AI. Novelty is crucial for any manuscript. Manuscripts with unoriginal ideas or language are quickly rejected by most journals⁵.  However, for the moment, AI-based editors may not catch all instances of plagiarism or copyright infringement in text, posing risks of misleading content or errors. 

Authors must understand that unpublished manuscripts uploaded for AI editing might become part of the data used to further train the AI model. Therefore, thoughtful consideration is crucial before using AI for manuscript revision or translation. 

When using AI in academic writing, authors should fully and accurately disclose its usage, apart from content control. Another reason why humans have to double-check AI-edited manuscripts is that AI cannot take responsibility for errors. Authors are solely responsible for errors made by AI-based editors⁶. This is also another reason why it is more convenient to work with human editors. 

AI-assisted technology has become more advanced in recent years, offering diverse applications. However, in the context of academic publishing, the usage of AI-based editing still requires careful judgment and review by the author. 

Editing is a fine art. It requires experience and understanding of a subject area and the nuances of academic writing. Professional language editing services can also help you effectively avoid the risks that AI modifications may bring. The Elsevier Language Services editing team, proficient across 100+ disciplines, enhances your manuscript, ensuring it aligns with the standards of top journals. Our excellent work can help increase your chances of publication. 

 

We also have some exciting news to share with you. The new and improved website of Elsevier Language Services is now online. It comes with a user-friendly interface and a more intuitive content layout. With improved ease of navigation, our website now guarantees researchers the ultimate browsing experience. So, enjoy our professional language services through a world-class online platform! 

 

Type in wordcount for Standard
Total:
Follow this link if your manuscript is longer than 12,000 words.
Upload

 

References 

  1. Chen, B. X. (2023, February 1). A.I. bots can’t report this column. but they can improve it. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/01/technology/personaltech/chatgpt-ai-bots-editing.html 
  2. Liu, R., Jia, C., Wei, J., Xu, G., & Vosoughi, S. (2022). Quantifying and alleviating political bias in language models. Artificial Intelligence, 304, 103654. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.artint.2021.103654 
  3. Singh, S. (2022). What you need to know about artificial intelligence in research and publishing. Editage Insights. https://www.editage.com/insights/what-you-need-to-know-about-artificial-intelligence-in-research-and-publishing 
  4. Tameez, H. (n.d.). BuzzFeed will start using AI to write quizzes and other content. Nieman Lab. https://www.niemanlab.org/2023/01/buzzfeed-will-start-using-ai-to-write-quizzes-and-other-content/ 
  5. Ali, J. (2010b). Manuscript rejection: Causes and remedies. Journal of Young Pharmacists, 2(1), 3–6. https://doi.org/10.4103/0975-1483.62205 
  6. Thorp, H.H. (2023). ChatGPT is fun, but not an author. Science, 379(6630). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adg7879.  
  7. Elsevier. (n.d.-c). The use of generative AI and AI-assisted technologies in writing for Elsevier. https://www.elsevier.com/about/policies/publishing-ethics-books/the-use-of-ai-and-ai-assisted-technologies-in-writing-for-elsevier 
Total
0
Shares
Post 0
Tweet 0
Share 0
Send 0
Message 0
Previous Article
How to Write Clear Civil Engineering Papers
  • Manuscript Preparation

How to Write Clear and Crisp Civil Engineering Papers? Here are 5 Key Tips to Consider

View Post
Next Article
what is a descriptive research design
  • Research Process

Descriptive Research Design and Its Myriad Uses

View Post
You May Also Like
Tips to Efficient Spellchecks
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

Three Tips to Efficient Spellchecks | Elsevier

submitting your manuscript to journals checklist
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

If You’re a Researcher, Remember These Before You Are Submitting Your Manuscript to Journals!

Errors in Academic English Writing
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

Navigating “Chinglish” Errors in Academic English Writing

editing experience with English-speaking experts
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

A profound editing experience with English-speaking experts: Elsevier Language Services to learn more!

Research Fraud: Falsification and Fabrication in Research Data
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

Research Fraud: Falsification and Fabrication in Research Data

Elsevier News Icon
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

Professor Anselmo Paiva: Using Computer Vision to Tackle Medical Issues with a Little Help from Elsevier Author Services

What is the main purpose of proofreading a paper?
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

What is the main purpose of proofreading a paper?

Systematic review vs meta-analysis
View Post
  • Manuscript Review

Systematic Review VS Meta-Analysis

  • Levels of evidence in research

    Levels of evidence in research

    • 5 minute read
    View Post
  • Risks of AI-assisted Academic Writing

    To Err is Not Human: The Dangers of AI-assisted Academic Writing

    • 4 minute read
    View Post
  • What is Observational Study Design and Types

    What is Observational Study Design and Types

    • 4 minute read
    View Post
  • Importance-of-Data-Collection

    When Data Speak, Listen: Importance of Data Collection and Analysis Methods

    • 3 minute read
    View Post
  • Looking for Medical Editing Services - Elsevier

    Looking for Medical Editing Services

    • 3 minute read
    View Post
More Posts
  • Latex format
    How to submit articles to Elsevier journals using LaTeX format 
    • 4 minute read
  • Academic paper format
    Submission 101: What format should be used for academic papers?
    • 4 minute read
  • how to write a cover letter
    How to Write a Cover Letter for Your Manuscript? Here are the Tips and Examples
    • 3 minute read
  • Being Mindful of Tone and Structure in Artilces
    Page-Turner Articles are More Than Just Good Arguments: Be Mindful of Tone and Structure!
    • 5 minute read
  • How to Ensure Inclusivity in Your Scientific Writing
    How to Ensure Inclusivity in Your Scientific Writing
    • 4 minute read
  • Tips to Efficient Spellchecks
    Three Tips to Efficient Spellchecks | Elsevier
    • 3 minute read
Price Calculator
Type in wordcount for Standard
Total:
Follow this link if your manuscript is longer than 12,000 words.
Upload
Learn more about
  • Research Process
  • Manuscript Preparation
  • Manuscript Review
  • Publication Process
  • Publication Recognition
  • News
Language Editing Services
Elsevier Author Services – Articles
  • Language Editing Services
  • Translation Services
Elsevier wordmark
Terms and conditions Privacy policy

Cookies are used by this site. To decline or learn more, visit our Cookies page.

All content on this site: Copyright © 2024 Elsevier B.V., its licensors, and contributors. All rights are reserved, including those for text and data mining, AI training, and similar technologies.

RELX Wordmark

Input your search keywords and press Enter.